![paladincompletes123006](https://investigations.namibian.com.na/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/paladincompletes123006.jpg)
By George Turner, Lazarus Amukshe and Shinovene Immanuel | 12 December 2018
THE Namibian government lost N$219 million in taxes from the sale of shares in one of the world’s largest uranium mines, Langer Heinrich, because the country’s tax avoidance law is not up to scratch.
An investigation by The Namibian and UK-based journalism organisation Finance Uncovered revealed that the Australian multi-national mining corporation, Paladin Energy, pocketed N$665 million after selling shares in the Langer Heinrich mine through a Mauritius-based offshore company.
Paladin argues that using an offshore holding company means they are not liable to pay tax in Namibia.
Tax on the proceeds of the sale would have amounted to N$219 million.
When presented with details of the joint investigation, the Namibian tax office said they were unaware of the Langer Heinrich deal, but in their view, taxes should have been paid on the proceeds.
Tax bosses admitted that problems with legislation mean they are unable to enforce the law on offshore transactions like that of Langer Heinrich.
Conducting transactions through Mauritius as a way to avoid paying taxes on the profits when assets are sold, is a well-known tax avoidance loophole used by many companies around the world.
THE LANGER HEINRICH URANIUM MINE
The Langer Heinrich mine in the Namib Desert was once Paladin Energy’s jewel in the crown. Paladin bought the mine in 2002 from Aztec Resources Limited for a mere N$86 000, and an agreement to pay a production royalty of 12 Australian cents per kilogramme of yellow cake sold was struck.
At the time, Langer Heinrich was little more than an empty piece of desert land. Attempts by Aztec Resources to develop the mine came to nothing due to the weak world uranium prices in the late 1990s. But by the time Paladin took over, uranium mining was once again the future.
Namibia is the world’s fourth-largest uranium producer, which is mainly used in nuclear power plants, and to manufacture nuclear weapons.
When Paladin acquired the mine in 2002, it immediately commissioned studies and plans, with construction starting in 2005.
The company set aside N$585 million to develop the mine, which was opened by former president Hifikepunye Pohamba in 2007.
Subsequently, the mine underwent two expansions – to improve capacity – and by 2014 was producing 5,6 million pounds of yellow cake a year, which would have been worth at least US$159 million on the international uranium markets.
THE DEAL
In 2011, the disaster at the Fukushima nuclear plant in Japan saw world uranium prices plunging, and by 2016, they had hit an 11-year low.
However, Langer Heinrich remained a valuable asset for Paladin. Three years after the Fukushima disaster, Paladin sold a 25% stake in the mine to the China National Nuclear Corporation for about N$2 billion, netting the company a healthy windfall, and they recorded a N$665 million profit – attributed to the sale of its shares.
However, not a cent in tax on this profit was paid to the Namibian government.
Disclosures by Paladin under the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative show that the company paid nothing in corporate tax to the Namibian government that year, although it paid N$101 million in payroll taxes and mineral royalties.
The N$219 million lost to the government is enough to pay for the construction of 35 112 toilets in Namibia’s rural areas.
CAPITAL GAINS
Until 2011, Namibia did not tax capital gains – the profit made when an asset is sold. The Income Tax Act of 2011 introduced a tax on profits from the sale of shares in a company holding a mining licence.
This tax was reduced from 34% to 33% in 2014, the year the Paladin sale took place. Had this been applied to the sale of Paladin’s shares in Langer Heinrich to the Chinese, the company would have had to pay N$219 million in tax.
For their part, Paladin claims no tax was due because instead of selling shares in the Namibian company operating the mine, it sold shares in the Mauritian holding company. Mauritius does not charge capital gains tax.
Paladin’s chief executive, Scott Sullivan, told Finance Uncovered: “Paladin’s investment in Langer Heinrich Uranium (Pty) Ltd, which owns the mineral licence for the Langer Heinrich mine, is ultimately held through Paladin’s subsidiary Langer Heinrich Mauritius Holdings Limited (LHMHL), which is a Mauritius-domiciled company.”
He said: “The 2011 act did not apply because Paladin sold 25% equity interest in Langer Heinrich Uranium (Pty) Ltd to China National Nuclear Corporation. There was no sale of Langer Heinrich’s Namibian mineral licence, nor was there any sale of shares in a company for a mineral licence.”
Sullivan denied that the Mauritian entity was established to avoid paying taxes in Namibia. He said the company was set up in 2006, years before Namibia introduced a capital gains tax on mining rights.
“Please note that this group structure was established almost six years before the amendments mentioned above to the definition of gross income contained in the 2011 act, and that offshore group holding structures are used by the industry worldwide.”
However, research by The Namibian found that although Langer Heinrich Mauritius Holdings was established in 2006, the company only appears in Paladin’s accounts from 2011.
This appears to indicate that the company was inserted into the corporate structure in response to Namibia’s attempts to tax profits on the sale of mining interests.
Sullivan claimed that the structure was not tax-driven.
“This group structure was established in 2006, for the purpose of holding Paladin’s investment in Langer Heinrich to enable project financing by foreign banks (without which project financing would not have been available, and the project with all its investment, employment and benefits would not have been built), and to provide specialised management and uranium marketing services to Langer Heinrich,” Sullivan stated.
According to Tax Justice Network Africa executive director Alvin Mosioma, companies like Paladin have been involved in “aggressive tax planning schemes” that leave most countries unable to collect enough revenue, primarily through Mauritius which has countless tax treaties with most countries.
A LACK OF ENFORCEMENT
While Paladin insists that no tax was due on the sale of shares, the Namibian tax office takes a different view.
After seeing the results of our investigation, Namibia’s commissioner of inland revenue, Justus Mwafongwe, told The Namibian “the place where the sales transaction takes place is irrelevant”, and “we agree that the indirect disposition of the shares by the investor should have been taxed in Namibia”.
Mwafongwe said they were unaware that the transaction had taken place since the Namibian tax system was a self-assessment system: this means the obligation was on companies to self-report their tax liabilities. This suggests that Paladin had not informed the Namibian tax authorities about the deal.
“We don’t have legislation that compels companies to disclose changes in their shareholding structure. It is, therefore, difficult to know when these transactions occur, unless it is where they state it in their financial statements.”
However, the taxman’s office said they lack enforcement mechanisms to hold offshore companies liable for Namibian taxes.
“A tax authority is usually challenged in enforcing these kinds of provisions because the company liable for such tax may not have any assets in the taxing jurisdiction.”
The mine was closed this year, waiting for a pickup in world uranium prices, forcing significant job losses at the plant.
The tax commissioner said government efforts are at an advanced stage of changing the law which will address how to enforce capital gains tax on indirect transfers where both the buyer and seller are offshore.
Options include requiring buyers to withhold part of the transaction fee to pay the tax, or placing the liability on the local company – all of which will come too late in the case of the Langer Heinrich transaction.
* This article was produced by The Namibian’s investigative unit in partnership with Finance Uncovered.
pin up yukle: pin up yukle – pin up onlayn kazino
pin-up online casino https://azerbaijancuisine.com/# pin up az?rbaycan
pin up casino azerbaycan
https://northern-doctors.org/# п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
mexican pharmacy: northern doctors – mexico drug stores pharmacies
mexican pharmacy: Mexico pharmacy that ship to usa – mexican pharmaceuticals online
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: mexican northern doctors – п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
mexican pharmaceuticals online: mexican pharmacy online – reputable mexican pharmacies online
reputable mexican pharmacies online buying prescription drugs in mexico п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
https://northern-doctors.org/# mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
mexican rx online: Mexico pharmacy that ship to usa – mexican rx online
mexican pharmaceuticals online: mexican pharmacy online – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
http://northern-doctors.org/# reputable mexican pharmacies online
mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs: northern doctors – mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
mexico drug stores pharmacies mexican pharmacy online mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
http://northern-doctors.org/# mexican pharmacy
medication from mexico pharmacy: northern doctors pharmacy – buying prescription drugs in mexico online
mexico drug stores pharmacies: northern doctors – mexico drug stores pharmacies
mexican rx online: northern doctors pharmacy – mexican mail order pharmacies
http://northern-doctors.org/# mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
mexican rx online: mexican northern doctors – mexico pharmacy
mexican mail order pharmacies mexican pharmacy northern doctors medicine in mexico pharmacies
https://northern-doctors.org/# best online pharmacies in mexico
mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexican northern doctors – pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
http://northern-doctors.org/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
purple pharmacy mexico price list: mexican pharmacy northern doctors – mexican drugstore online
mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs northern doctors pharmacy п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: mexican northern doctors – mexico pharmacy
https://northern-doctors.org/# mexican pharmacy
п»їbest mexican online pharmacies: mexican pharmacy online – pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
http://northern-doctors.org/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
mexican drugstore online: mexican drugstore online – buying prescription drugs in mexico
mexico drug stores pharmacies: buying from online mexican pharmacy – buying prescription drugs in mexico online
http://northern-doctors.org/# mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
mexican pharmacy: buying prescription drugs in mexico online – mexican pharmacy
mexico drug stores pharmacies mexican pharmacy northern doctors best online pharmacies in mexico
medication from mexico pharmacy: mexican pharmacy online – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
buying from online mexican pharmacy: reputable mexican pharmacies online – purple pharmacy mexico price list
https://northern-doctors.org/# buying prescription drugs in mexico
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: northern doctors pharmacy – medication from mexico pharmacy
reputable mexican pharmacies online: mexican pharmacy online – mexican drugstore online
buying prescription drugs in mexico: mexican pharmacy – medication from mexico pharmacy
mexican pharmaceuticals online: mexican pharmacy northern doctors – mexican mail order pharmacies
medicine in mexico pharmacies mexican pharmacy online mexican pharmaceuticals online
https://northern-doctors.org/# medicine in mexico pharmacies
best online pharmacies in mexico: mexican pharmacy northern doctors – mexico drug stores pharmacies
mexican drugstore online: northern doctors pharmacy – best online pharmacies in mexico
mexican rx online: northern doctors – medicine in mexico pharmacies
mexican pharmaceuticals online: northern doctors pharmacy – buying prescription drugs in mexico online
https://northern-doctors.org/# medication from mexico pharmacy
buying from online mexican pharmacy: mexican pharmacy – mexican mail order pharmacies
buying from online mexican pharmacy [url=http://northern-doctors.org/#]mexican pharmacy online[/url] mexican rx online
mexican drugstore online: mexican northern doctors – buying from online mexican pharmacy
https://northern-doctors.org/# reputable mexican pharmacies online
mexican pharmacy: reputable mexican pharmacies online – п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
https://cmqpharma.com/# buying prescription drugs in mexico online
mexican mail order pharmacies
mexican rx online mexico pharmacy purple pharmacy mexico price list
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa: online mexican pharmacy – buying from online mexican pharmacy
purple pharmacy mexico price list cmq pharma mexican pharmacy medication from mexico pharmacy
mexico drug stores pharmacies cmq pharma buying prescription drugs in mexico online
buying prescription drugs in mexico mexican pharmacy medicine in mexico pharmacies
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs mexican pharmacy online purple pharmacy mexico price list
mexican rx online cmq pharma mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
purple pharmacy mexico price list online mexican pharmacy mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
mexican mail order pharmacies mexican online pharmacy mexican mail order pharmacies
mexican pharmacy cmq mexican pharmacy online mexican pharmacy
https://cmqpharma.com/# purple pharmacy mexico price list
mexican pharmaceuticals online
buying prescription drugs in mexico online cmq pharma mexican pharmacy
Very interesting subject, appreciate it for putting up.Raise your business
medication from mexico pharmacy: п»їbest mexican online pharmacies – buying prescription drugs in mexico
https://canadapharmast.com/# buying from canadian pharmacies
reputable indian pharmacies indianpharmacy com indianpharmacy com
Online medicine home delivery: indian pharmacy – world pharmacy india
buy prescription drugs from india: indianpharmacy com – indian pharmacy
pet meds without vet prescription canada onlinecanadianpharmacy canada drugs online reviews
http://canadapharmast.com/# canadian drugstore online
safe reliable canadian pharmacy: safe online pharmacies in canada – canadian pharmacy online store
mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexico drug stores pharmacies – mexican pharmaceuticals online
п»їbest mexican online pharmacies: mexican mail order pharmacies – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
mexican drugstore online: buying prescription drugs in mexico – pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
top 10 pharmacies in india indianpharmacy com top online pharmacy india
http://indiapharmast.com/# indian pharmacy online
legit canadian online pharmacy: canadian pharmacy india – canadian discount pharmacy
п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india india pharmacy buy prescription drugs from india
top 10 online pharmacy in india: mail order pharmacy india – india online pharmacy
indian pharmacy: best online pharmacy india – buy prescription drugs from india
canadian pharmacy phone number: canadian pharmacy 24h com – my canadian pharmacy review
https://foruspharma.com/# mexican mail order pharmacies
buy canadian drugs: canada cloud pharmacy – legit canadian pharmacy online
online canadian pharmacy reviews: canadian pharmacy service – canadian valley pharmacy
canadian pharmacy king reviews safe canadian pharmacy 77 canadian pharmacy
mexican mail order pharmacies: mexico drug stores pharmacies – mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
http://canadapharmast.com/# maple leaf pharmacy in canada
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
purple pharmacy mexico price list: buying prescription drugs in mexico online – mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
canadian pharmacy cheap: canadian pharmacy near me – northwest canadian pharmacy
mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexican drugstore online – medicine in mexico pharmacies
http://foruspharma.com/# mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
global pharmacy canada: canadian family pharmacy – safe reliable canadian pharmacy
canadian pharmacy oxycodone: reputable canadian online pharmacies – canada drug pharmacy
is canadian pharmacy legit canadian compounding pharmacy canadadrugpharmacy com
Online medicine order: buy prescription drugs from india – reputable indian online pharmacy
medication from mexico pharmacy: mexican mail order pharmacies – best online pharmacies in mexico
reputable indian pharmacies: indian pharmacy – reputable indian online pharmacy
https://clomiddelivery.pro/# can i buy cheap clomid for sale
paxlovid for sale: Paxlovid over the counter – buy paxlovid online
paxlovid pill: paxlovid pill – п»їpaxlovid
http://clomiddelivery.pro/# buy generic clomid pill
https://paxloviddelivery.pro/# paxlovid pill
https://clomiddelivery.pro/# how to buy clomid no prescription
http://ciprodelivery.pro/# ciprofloxacin over the counter
where to buy amoxicillin pharmacy: buy amoxicillin 500mg usa – amoxicillin for sale online
http://amoxildelivery.pro/# can we buy amoxcillin 500mg on ebay without prescription
https://clomiddelivery.pro/# where can i buy generic clomid now
https://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# doxycycline hyclate capsules
can you buy amoxicillin over the counter canada [url=https://amoxildelivery.pro/#]where can i buy amoxicillin over the counter uk[/url] buy amoxil
clomid brand name: where to get generic clomid – can i purchase cheap clomid without rx
https://paxloviddelivery.pro/# paxlovid generic
http://ciprodelivery.pro/# ciprofloxacin generic price
paxlovid covid: paxlovid india – paxlovid pill
https://paxloviddelivery.pro/# п»їpaxlovid
cipro for sale: buy cipro – where to buy cipro online
https://clomiddelivery.pro/# can i purchase clomid tablets
https://paxloviddelivery.pro/# paxlovid cost without insurance
http://amoxildelivery.pro/# amoxicillin 500 mg purchase without prescription
can you buy clomid: can you buy clomid prices – where can i buy cheap clomid without prescription
https://clomiddelivery.pro/# can you get clomid for sale
http://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# otc doxycycline no prescription
ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online: where can i buy cipro online – cipro for sale
http://amoxildelivery.pro/# amoxicillin 500 mg cost
https://clomiddelivery.pro/# can you buy generic clomid price
cipro 500mg best prices: antibiotics cipro – buy cipro online
buy cipro cheap: ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price – buy cipro
ciprofloxacin order online: buy cipro cheap – buy cipro online without prescription
buy doxycycline 100mg canada: doxycycline 40 mg capsule – buy doxycycline 50 mg
buy cipro online canada: ciprofloxacin order online – cipro for sale