![Esau goes for broke on pilchards](https://investigations.namibian.com.na/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Esau-goes-for-broke-on-pilchards.png)
By Shinovene Immanuel | 10 February 2017
FISHERIES minister Bernhard Esau has ignored advice from scientists and his officials and is pushing ahead with the allocation of pilchard quotas, a species declared as “depleted” and in danger of extinction from Namibian waters.
The Namibian understands that Esau has already gone to Cabinet to rubber-stamp his decision to exploit the sardines, going as far as hiding some of the most critical warnings from experts and from political colleagues.
Esau denied allegations that he is ignoring recommendations from his scientists, and said that he is not pushing for the interests of pilchard companies.
In his request to Cabinet, Esau has reportedly underplayed scientific research showing that pilchard has been overfished for the past several years, and that it may not recover again, even if a ban of five years was put in place.
Pilchard fishing has been the most lucrative species in the industry, generating a lot of cash for those Esau and former fishing ministers gave fishing rights to. Pilchard is a well-known fish species in Namibian households, and is famously distributed in cans under well-known brands such as Lucky Star.
Insiders in the fisheries ministry told The Namibian this week that Esau wants Cabinet to approve the fishing of pilchards, despite warnings from scientists in his ministry.
“The sardine stock size is currently estimated at virtually zero level, and the natural mortality is considered to be very high, while recruitment has been poor for five consecutive years,” said an insider, stating that they have used the same wording to warn the minister, but feared the warnings were being ignored.
According to the source, the pilchard companies have struggled to fulfil their allocated total allowable catch over the past few years, even when their catching period was extended by the ministry, a sign of a depleted resource in Namibian waters.
Every year or fishing season, the minister of fisheries seeks permission from Cabinet to declare a “total allowable catch”, which refers to a limit set by government on how much fish will be caught during a season.
Fisheries ministry insiders said Esau wants to propose that 14 000 metric tonnes of pilchard be harvested for the 2017 fishing season. His motives, sources said, are driven mainly by pressure from people who are lobbying him to make as much cash in the shortest time as possible.
This is despite evidence that 2016 fishing targets were not met because of the declining stock in the sea.
Last year, Cabinet, on the recommendations of Esau, approved the harvesting of 10 000 metric tonnes, but the companies only managed to catch 3 400 metric tonnes (34%) of that target.
Officials said fishing companies stopped their pursuit of pilchards because they were losing money in the hopeless search for the fish.
According to a report in The Namibian in 2006, concerns about the stock of pilchards started as far back as in the mid-1990s. That news report said the total allowable catch was reduced from 125 000 metric tonnes in 1994 to 40 000 metric tonnes in 1995, and reduced again by 20 000 metric tonnes in 1996. Now, statistics show that fishing companies struggle to land 3 000 metric tonnes per year.
Experts said concern over the possible extinction of pilchard is so deep because no recovery will be achieved if strict measures are not enforced.
In fact, scientists said, a five-year ban on pilchard fishing in Namibia will not be enough to recover its stock, even though it will minimise fishing pressure on the species.
Experts also warned that no sardine spawn was found between March and April last year.
A source said this is an indication of a “very low sardine adult stock”.
As the third-largest employer in the fishing sector with 10%, workers in the pilchard industry have dropped from 1 900 to 950, which represents a decline of around 50% from 2015 to 2016.
The Namibian has learnt that no investment was made into the pilchard industry in 2016, and the socio-economic contribution decreased from N$1,7 million in 2015 to N$245 000.
Some Cabinet members, known to own fishing companies or with links to fishing business associates, are said to be pushing for the maximum exploitation of fish stock.
Sources said Esau, supported by a few Cabinet colleagues such as attorney general Sacky Shanghala, wants to justify and convince Cabinet to approve the fishing of pilchards by saying that the absence of pilchard fishing will reduce economic benefits, such as a negative impact on Namibian pilchard right holders who do not own vessels and factories.
According to people familiar with how he has sidelined scientific research, Esau is using the threat of job losses to cover up the fact that his main reason is to help those who want to make a quick buck from the industry.
The fisheries ministry is accused of double standards by being strongly against phosphate mining, which it says might negatively affect fishing stock, while at the same time depleting species, including pilchards.
I WAS TOLD…
Esau told The Namibian yesterday that claims that he is ignoring his scientists are not true because he decided to recommend 14 000 metric tonnes for this year via recommendations by the Marine Resource Advisory Council made up of scientists, trade unions and other officials.
“I acted on the advice of the advisory council,” he said.
Esau claims that he wanted to temporarily ban the fishing of pilchards, but the advisory council told him not to.
He said 4 000 metric tonnes of the 14 000 metric tonnes will go to researching the pilchard industry offshore, while 10 000 metric tonnes is for right holders.
The minister added that the industry had informed him that pilchards have gone into deeper waters, making it difficult for fishing companies to catch beyond the limits set by government. Unlike other fishing companies in species such as horse mackerel (maasbanker) which use trawlers, pilchard companies use nets that do not go into deep waters.
Esau also denied allegations that he is protecting the interest of associates and business people.
The attorney general has been Esau’s supporter in Cabinet on many occasions.
“It is not about Shanghala supporting Esau,” Shanghala said, adding that Esau is guided by the Constitution when allocating marine resources.
In this case, Esau made a decision based on advice from the advisory council, which was guided by scientific factors.
BLAME THE SEALS
One of the companies which has harvested pilchards since the 1940s is Etosha Fishing, a Namibian-registered company that also produces Lucky Star pilchards for the Namibian market.
Etosha Fishing is 45% owned by South African company Oceana Group (the owner of Lucky Star), while 30% is owned by the Government Institutions Pension Fund.
Four Namibian rights holders own a combined 20% stake (5% each), while the remaining 5% is owned by local business people.
Etosha Fishing’s managing director, Pieter Greeff, said “we know pilchard has been under pressure”.
He, however, said the idea of banning the fishing of pilchards is not the solution because the sector will not recover. Greeff claimed that Etosha Fishing employs 650 people for the fishing season.
He said pilchard catchers failed to catch the quotas last year because the pilchards are migrating into deeper waters, which is difficult to assess, unlike in the past when they were closer to land.
Greeff said besides the migration, seals are also consuming more fish than what companies are catching per year.
“Seals are going to eat the fish anyway. Seals are eating pilchards more than what the entire fishing industry is catching,” he stated.
*This story was produced by The Namibian’s investigative unit. Send us story tips via your secure email to: [email protected]
pin up giris: pin up azerbaijan – pin up 306
pin up azerbaijan https://azerbaijancuisine.com/# pin up
pin-up 306
https://northern-doctors.org/# purple pharmacy mexico price list
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: northern doctors pharmacy – mexico drug stores pharmacies
https://northern-doctors.org/# buying prescription drugs in mexico online
mexican rx online: Mexico pharmacy that ship to usa – mexican drugstore online
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa [url=https://northern-doctors.org/#]mexican pharmacy northern doctors[/url] buying from online mexican pharmacy
mexican rx online: Mexico pharmacy that ship to usa – buying prescription drugs in mexico online
https://northern-doctors.org/# mexican pharmacy
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: mexican pharmaceuticals online – medicine in mexico pharmacies
http://northern-doctors.org/# mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
mexico pharmacy: mexican pharmacy online – mexico pharmacy
purple pharmacy mexico price list [url=https://northern-doctors.org/#]buying prescription drugs in mexico online[/url] mexico drug stores pharmacies
https://northern-doctors.org/# mexican rx online
mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexican pharmacy – medicine in mexico pharmacies
https://northern-doctors.org/# mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa: mexican pharmacy northern doctors – mexican drugstore online
mexico drug stores pharmacies: northern doctors – mexican mail order pharmacies
mexican mail order pharmacies: northern doctors – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
mexican drugstore online [url=http://northern-doctors.org/#]northern doctors[/url] pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
http://northern-doctors.org/# mexican rx online
mexican drugstore online: mexican northern doctors – п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs: mexican pharmacy northern doctors – buying prescription drugs in mexico online
https://northern-doctors.org/# purple pharmacy mexico price list
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: mexican pharmacy – purple pharmacy mexico price list
https://northern-doctors.org/# buying prescription drugs in mexico
medicine in mexico pharmacies: northern doctors pharmacy – best online pharmacies in mexico
mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs [url=https://northern-doctors.org/#]northern doctors[/url] pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
https://northern-doctors.org/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
buying from online mexican pharmacy: mexican pharmacy northern doctors – pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
http://northern-doctors.org/# mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
п»їbest mexican online pharmacies: mexican northern doctors – pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs [url=http://northern-doctors.org/#]Mexico pharmacy that ship to usa[/url] п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
http://northern-doctors.org/# mexican drugstore online
best online pharmacies in mexico: northern doctors pharmacy – mexican pharmacy
medication from mexico pharmacy: mexican pharmacy – purple pharmacy mexico price list
https://northern-doctors.org/# purple pharmacy mexico price list
mexican mail order pharmacies: mexican pharmacy – reputable mexican pharmacies online
mexican mail order pharmacies: mexican pharmacy – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
https://northern-doctors.org/# buying prescription drugs in mexico online
buying prescription drugs in mexico: mexican northern doctors – mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
mexico drug stores pharmacies [url=http://northern-doctors.org/#]mexican pharmacy online[/url] mexican drugstore online
medicine in mexico pharmacies: mexican pharmacy online – medicine in mexico pharmacies
best online pharmacies in mexico: northern doctors pharmacy – mexican pharmaceuticals online
https://northern-doctors.org/# mexican pharmaceuticals online
medication from mexico pharmacy: mexican drugstore online – reputable mexican pharmacies online
mexico pharmacy: Mexico pharmacy that ship to usa – best online pharmacies in mexico
http://northern-doctors.org/# mexican rx online
buying from online mexican pharmacy: mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs – п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
https://northern-doctors.org/# mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
mexican rx online: mexican pharmacy online – mexican drugstore online
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs [url=https://northern-doctors.org/#]Mexico pharmacy that ship to usa[/url] buying prescription drugs in mexico
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs: northern doctors – best online pharmacies in mexico
purple pharmacy mexico price list: northern doctors – buying prescription drugs in mexico
http://northern-doctors.org/# medication from mexico pharmacy
mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexican pharmacy northern doctors – mexican rx online
medicine in mexico pharmacies: mexican rx online – mexico drug stores pharmacies
https://northern-doctors.org/# mexican rx online
buying prescription drugs in mexico online: mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs – buying from online mexican pharmacy
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs [url=https://northern-doctors.org/#]mexican pharmacy[/url] mexican mail order pharmacies
reputable mexican pharmacies online: mexican pharmacy northern doctors – buying prescription drugs in mexico
https://northern-doctors.org/# mexico pharmacy
mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs [url=https://cmqpharma.com/#]cmq pharma[/url] mexican rx online
https://cmqpharma.online/# purple pharmacy mexico price list
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
mexican mail order pharmacies: mexican pharmacy online – medication from mexico pharmacy
mexico drug stores pharmacies [url=https://cmqpharma.com/#]mexican pharmacy online[/url] mexican rx online
buying prescription drugs in mexico [url=https://cmqpharma.com/#]mexico pharmacy[/url] п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa [url=http://cmqpharma.com/#]cmqpharma.com[/url] mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa [url=http://cmqpharma.com/#]buying prescription drugs in mexico online[/url] best online pharmacies in mexico
buying prescription drugs in mexico
https://cmqpharma.com/# reputable mexican pharmacies online
mexican drugstore online
mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs [url=https://cmqpharma.com/#]mexican pharmacy[/url] п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
purple pharmacy mexico price list [url=https://cmqpharma.online/#]mexican pharmacy online[/url] mexico drug stores pharmacies
mexico drug stores pharmacies [url=http://cmqpharma.com/#]cmq mexican pharmacy online[/url] mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
mexican drugstore online [url=https://cmqpharma.com/#]mexican mail order pharmacies[/url] mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs [url=https://cmqpharma.com/#]mexico pharmacy[/url] mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: medicine in mexico pharmacies – mexican mail order pharmacies
buy medicines online in india [url=http://indiapharmast.com/#]best online pharmacy india[/url] best india pharmacy
https://canadapharmast.online/# online canadian pharmacy reviews
mexican mail order pharmacies: buying prescription drugs in mexico online – mexican pharmacy
india pharmacy: Online medicine order – best india pharmacy
reputable mexican pharmacies online: mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa – mexico drug stores pharmacies
canadian pharmacy online [url=http://canadapharmast.com/#]cross border pharmacy canada[/url] canadian online drugstore
best online pharmacy india: п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india – best online pharmacy india
http://indiapharmast.com/# india pharmacy
indian pharmacy online: india pharmacy – india pharmacy mail order
top online pharmacy india [url=https://indiapharmast.com/#]online pharmacy india[/url] buy prescription drugs from india
canadian pharmacy scam: rate canadian pharmacies – my canadian pharmacy review
canadian pharmacies that deliver to the us: maple leaf pharmacy in canada – legit canadian pharmacy
indian pharmacy online: п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india – buy prescription drugs from india
canada pharmacy 24h [url=https://canadapharmast.online/#]reddit canadian pharmacy[/url] canada pharmacy reviews
mexican mail order pharmacies: buying from online mexican pharmacy – mexican pharmaceuticals online
india pharmacy mail order: indian pharmacies safe – india pharmacy
buying from online mexican pharmacy: buying from online mexican pharmacy – buying prescription drugs in mexico online
paxlovid pill: paxlovid buy – paxlovid generic
https://amoxildelivery.pro/# amoxicillin tablet 500mg
cheapest doxycycline without prescrtiption [url=http://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/#]doxycycline 100mg price south africa[/url] medication doxycycline 100mg
http://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# 631311 doxycycline
http://amoxildelivery.pro/# can i buy amoxicillin over the counter
http://clomiddelivery.pro/# how to buy cheap clomid tablets
where can i get doxycycline uk [url=https://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/#]doxycycline for sale online[/url] doxycycline pills price in south africa
ciprofloxacin generic price: buy cipro without rx – where can i buy cipro online
http://ciprodelivery.pro/# buy cipro cheap
https://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# doxycycline online australia
doxycycline 100mg price in india [url=https://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/#]doxycycline order online canada[/url] doxycycline 100mg capsules price in india
http://clomiddelivery.pro/# cost of cheap clomid tablets
cipro for sale: buy cipro online canada – ciprofloxacin
http://clomiddelivery.pro/# order generic clomid without insurance
where to get doxycycline in singapore [url=https://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/#]generic doxycycline 3626[/url] doxycycline india pharmacy
https://amoxildelivery.pro/# amoxicillin 875 125 mg tab
http://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# doxycycline 50 mg cost
price of doxycycline in india [url=https://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/#]doxycycline 100mg canada[/url] doxycycline 100mg capsules buy
paxlovid price: Paxlovid buy online – paxlovid covid
https://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# price of doxycycline 100mg
http://clomiddelivery.pro/# can i get cheap clomid without rx
buy cipro online [url=https://ciprodelivery.pro/#]buy cipro[/url] cipro online no prescription in the usa
http://clomiddelivery.pro/# buying generic clomid without dr prescription
where can i buy amoxicillin over the counter: amoxicillin 500mg capsules price – amoxicillin 500mg capsule
http://ciprodelivery.pro/# buy cipro
http://clomiddelivery.pro/# can i order generic clomid pill
clomid without insurance [url=http://clomiddelivery.pro/#]where to get generic clomid without prescription[/url] how can i get generic clomid without insurance
Paxlovid over the counter: п»їpaxlovid – paxlovid generic
https://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# how to get doxycycline online
paxlovid generic: paxlovid pill – paxlovid price